9.23.2009

A Guest Blogger: Jared "Numbnuts" Burgan

Jared Burgan is my brother. He will graduate from the University of Delaware on May 10, 2010 with a BM in Music Education. He can be reached at jaredburgan@gmail.com.

This is my most recent photograph of Jared. Looking good as always:




Without further adieu:

When I Go- Ask Me When I Get Back
Jared Burgan
In December of 2005 I enlisted in the US Army Reservist as a 42R- Army Bandsman (we can save the band jokes for later). It was to this day the most brash and least thought out decision I’ve made in my life; when people ask me why I enlisted I really don’t have an answer. My initial experiences with being in the military (MEPS and Basic Training) were awful just as they are for most people. That with the close proximity of my mother’s death made my first few years in the Army terrible. I wanted nothing more than serve my time and be out.

As my enlistment progressed the Army began to grow on me. That coupled with a diminishing interest in my collegiate studies (music education) I saw the possibility of me making a career out of the military a more likely path I’d be taking. As such I am currently to re-class my MOS to 19D- Cavalry Scout. I’ve gotten used to surprised comments and disappointed looks as I tell this to my friends and family as I field the standard questions of, “Why would you want to do this now?” to less frequent but more sincere, “Why do you want to be part of the war machine?” Not all of the feedback has been negative though. “This is something you’d be good at” or “I can see you doing this” are the most common responses from these people. It hasn’t been an easy decision and it’ll take me a while to follow through with it as I get other things in order.

What I really want to talk about though is the ever-pervading question of “Why? Why would you want to join the Army, especially during a war?” And for me, where I am in my life, it is hard to explain to people that it is something I feel like I need to do. Part of it is legacy. My cousin has been in since the late 1980’s and is currently serving as a company first sergeant. Both of my grandfathers served during World War II. One of them was awarded two Silver Stars, a Purple Heart, and aided in the liberation of a concentration camp. Another part of it is a sense of service. This part is hard for people to understand, especially in an era of American society where any sense of service of any kind is lost in an elitist sense of “that isn’t for me”. That leads me to my third reason. I was fortunate enough to have the option of enlisting. Other people due to their own circumstances are left with the military as their only option for a successful future. This doesn’t demean their commitment but it does put into perspective a dangerously growing gap between the haves and the have-nots.

The last eight years have a put a serious strain on the public’s opinion of the military and those who serve. We are caught in an occupation in one country and an increasingly violent insurgency in another. And amidst this we’ve turned military service into political leanings- in efforts to point blame on a particular party we’ve neglected and abandoned the men and women who serve our country. We’ve turned “Why do you serve?” into “How could you possibly do this now?” We’ve written off a sense of service simply as necessity- someone just trying to scrape by. We’ve turned the efforts of men and women overseas into fodder for a left-wing/ right-wing argument over who is right or should we even keep bothering in these countries? Soldiers, Marines, sailors and airmen have volunteer for a job that has people with little to no military experience directing the course of their lives. So as civilians and politicians argue over policy we’ve abandoned men and women over seas to fight wars with no support.

The last eight years have made it very easy for a lot of people in this country to judge the actions of men and women over seas, and worse to pass judgment on why these people chose to do what they do. Asking soldiers why they serve is trying to understand why they volunteer for months over seas away from families, why they put themselves in a firefight, or why they risk their lives for the men and women next to them. The truth is though that if it is something someone never experiences, it is something that can never be understood.

4 comments:

A P said...

I didn't read this post yet, but I did read the title. I'm sure a lot of people have called Jared, numbnuts, but for some reason it makes me think of Uncle Harold. I feel like, if anyone could have made this commonplace slander stick as a nickname it was him.
Picturing this makes me happy.

cjb said...

I disagree with what Jared says about service. "Another part of it is a sense of service. This part is hard for people to understand, especially in an era of American society where any sense of service of any kind is lost in an elitist sense of “that isn’t for me”."

I've tried to explain to Jared that there are hundreds if not thousands of NGO, Non-profit, and peaceful organizations that exist who need intelligent and hard working individuals working for them to help them succeed. Why does Jared's sense of service have to include the use automatic rifles, machine guns, cluster bombs, etc? Why doesn't Jared think that teaching children in this country is in itself a service, and a VITAL service at that? How many children could Jared have affected as a teacher who would then grow up with such a different outlook on life, who wouldn't necessarily be "stuck" into enlisting in the armed forces?

Another thing that I don't think Jared can see clearly is that the civilians in this country support their soldiers more than the politicians do! How often do we see in the news the failure of our government to take care of veterans after they have given everything they have? Why do politicians use false intelligence to use the army as a means to their own ends? The last time the US military was properly and effectively used as a peace keeping force was in post-war Germany and with the air-support of the Marshall Plan. Since then politicians and lobbyists have used the armed forces to meet their own political and financial ends.

Jared I support the armed forces by DEMANDING that you aren't abused by scheming politicians and corporate greed! How can you not see that?

jared said...

There is no shortage of people volunteering for organizations like Teach for America or the Peace Corps. There are enough people willing to answer the call for these groups. Why then is it so hard to understand that this is where I feel I should serve?

In regards to the European occupation after WWII- the occupation was successful because the entire country was committed to defeating a perceived enemy. Do you really think that from 1947-1991 there was no falsified intelligence to keep troops occupying territories of interest? In any case, would it have been better to not occupy these territories so the the Soviet Army could have aggressively expanded?

Since Vietnam the effectiveness of the US Military is contingent upon the popularity of the conflict amongst the American public. The possibility of being effective in countries like Somalia, Bosnia and Kosovo is limited by what the American public sees is the 24-hour news media coverage that stresses and only covers American casualties. Rarely do you ever hear about Marines escorting Iraqi children to class, the Hospital Corpsman giving aide to civilians or the Soldiers providing security at polling points so that Iraqi citizens can practice democracy.

And who elects these politicians? Americans (when they decide they feel like voting) can chose who is sending American men and women over seas. The tepid response of "I support the troops and not the war" does little to boost troop moral. That saying is along the lines of "She's got a great personality, but..." Say it however you want, the girl is still fat and something you're not into.

If civilians really supported the troops they'd be demanding that the Soldiers and Marines in Afghanistan were getting the necessities to maintain a successful counterinsurgency. If civilians really cared about our service men and women they wouldn't just simply be outraged by poor care at VA facilities. Rather they would donate their time at VA hospitals and homes. They would support the efforts of the USO and the various organizations set up to help returning troops; non-profits that get lost in the sea of other seemingly "better" organizations.

It doesn't do a Soldier or a Marine any good by turning your back on them while you "demand" action from politicians

jb. said...

incredibly well-written ... but i'll keep my content comments under wrap.